Prince Edward Island 1871 Penny Identification and Value Guide

1871 Prince Edward Island penny with detail on obverse and reverse design features
Quick answer

The 1871 cent is the only coin Prince Edward Island issued, struck two years before the island joined Canada. Values depend on grade and colour, so identify the coin and grade it before you price it.

Prices in this guide are estimates for comparable coins, based on price guides and auction results when it was last updated (May 15, 2026). They are not an appraisal; check recent sold results before you buy or sell.

The Prince Edward Island 1871 penny, a rare collector's item, can be worth over $1,000 depending on condition. It has unique features such as the centered bust and distinctive color that attract collectors. Learn how to spot the real deal and where values land.

A Brief History of the 1871 PEI Penny

The Prince Edward Island 1871 penny was minted during a unique time when the island was still a British colony. The penny was introduced partly due to the island's isolation and the need for localized currency. With only about 2 million minted, surviving examples are quite rare. For more, see our coin value guide.

Identifying the 1871 PEI Penny

The 1871 PEI penny is known for its distinctive designs. The obverse showcases a portrait of Queen Victoria, easily recognizable by the head centering and detail in her hair. The reverse features a crowned harp intertwined with a maple leaf. The color can vary, but a darker tone often indicates age and authenticity. For more, see our photo identifier walkthrough.

Factors Affecting the Value of the 1871 PEI Penny

Condition is paramount when valuing these pennies, with mint state coins being exceptionally desirable. Factors like die cracks or misalignment can also affect value. Tracking auction results on Heritage Auctions can provide insights on current market trends.

Recent Sales and Auction Records

Prices for PEI 1871 pennies vary widely based on condition and rarity of features. A well-preserved example might fetch over $1,000 at Stack's Bowers. Always consider professional grading by services like PCGS or NGC for an accurate valuation.

Where to Buy and Sell 1871 PEI Pennies

To buy or sell PEI pennies, consider platforms like Coin World or local auctions. Networking with members of the ANA can also lead to trustworthy transactions. Ensure all coins are authenticated before any transaction.

Maintaining and Storing Your Collection

Proper storage is key to preserving coins like the 1871 PEI penny. Use acid-free holders and store them in temperature-controlled environments. The Old Coin Identifier page offers additional tips on maintaining older coins.

FAQ

Identify your coin in seconds

Photograph both sides. Coinara reads the date, mint mark, and design, then shows an estimated value range with grade guidance.

Download on the App Store
Free download · iPhone, iPad & Android
Scan with your phone camera
Coinara result screen showing an identified coin and its value range
Tuğberk Can Özen
Founder, OBZENA LLC

Tuğberk Can Özen is the founder of OBZENA LLC and the maker of Coinara, an AI coin identification app. Tuğberk writes and edits the guides on this site with the help of AI drafting tools and is not a professional numismatist or appraiser.

More from Tuğberk Can Özen

Recommended

How to Authenticate Russian Imperial Coins for New Collectors
Aug 15, 2026
Wheat Penny Identification Guide: 1909-1958 Year-by-Year
May 21, 2026
16 Canadian Loonie 1 Dollar Errors and Varieties Worth Hunting
May 20, 2026
How to Tell if a Coin is Silver: 4 At-Home Tests That Work
May 29, 2026
20 Most Valuable Foreign Coins American Collectors Want
Jun 19, 2026

Related articles

Popular guides

Coin Value CheckerCoin Identifier by PhotoOld Coin IdentifierFree Coin IdentifierRare Coins Worth MoneyBest Coin Identifier Apps

Latest articles

Mint Marks on US Coins: Where to Find Them
Oct 27, 2026
Coin Scanner: Scan a Coin With Your Phone to Identify It
Sep 25, 2026
How to Authenticate Russian Imperial Coins for New Collectors
Aug 15, 2026
Kingdom of Two Sicilies Coins: Identification and Value Guide
Jul 23, 2026
Identify now